The vote fails when I don't think it should #3


  • New
  • Defect
Open
Assigned to _ForgeUser7759659
  • _ForgeUser634414 created this issue Feb 15, 2012

    What steps will reproduce the problem?
    1. settings:
        minimumPercent: 50
        minimumPlayers: 2
        timeout: 45

    2. Vote fails with "The vote failed! 2/3"

    What is the expected output? What do you see instead?

    Vote should pass but The vote failed! 2/3

    What version of the product are you using?

    MajorityVote v1.0

    Do you have an error log of what happened?

    The vote failed! 2/3

    Please provide any additional information below.

    The vote just fails when I don't think it should fail.

    In this case, perhaps it would also be possible to exclude the argument from the vote.

    For example /vote ban %arg%
    The %arg% (player) in question could optionally not have a say in the vote.
    This might be possible by using another argument like %arg%%exclude% or having another line in the config under that particular option:
    exclude: %arg%

  • _ForgeUser634414 added the tags New Defect Feb 15, 2012
  • _ForgeUser634414 posted a comment Feb 16, 2012

    Also, the vote shouldn't fail when people who don't have permissions to vote shouldn't be included in the vote.

    For example: /vote citizen playername

    The player is a visitor at first without permissions to vote. The community votes them to be a citizen but the vote fails because of the previous issue and because they can't vote due to not having permission to vote in the first place. So I propose also that users without permissions to vote should not be included in the decision of whether the vote fails or passes.

  • _ForgeUser634414 posted a comment Feb 18, 2012

    Was thinking the exclude: option could allow for a comma separated list of players names, so for example I can add %arg% as one of those items but also exclude myself from the voting of that particular vote if I don't want to be involved with it and let the community deal with it instead.

  • _ForgeUser4439668 posted a comment Feb 18, 2012

    On version 1, because 1.1 errors on load, the vote does not pass unless it is 100% of the people.


To post a comment, please login or register a new account.